Have that swag, young Mobley. Thats why Jokic can still be better than Giannis despite not being that good defensively. He was in the 99th percentile in D-LEBRON, 86th percentile in Defensive Real Plus-Minus and 97th percentile in Defensive RAPTOR. Dont show this to raptors fans lol. As big as he is Wood is listed at 6-foot-10 he's perfectly content spotting up on the 3-point line and waiting for kickouts. My gut tells me a scatter plot of true offensive impact vs. defensive impact would have slight negative correlation. Your default site has been set for 7 days, Why Christian Wood is this offseason's most interesting free agent, As John Hollinger of The Athletic wrote recently. The effect is linear and has been consistently replicated. Giannis can be great at both offense and defense and be +4 for both. During the Warriors dynastic run from 2015 to 19, they had a series of players who could switch onto any position, including defensive stalwarts who bugged the NBAs elite wings. They matter to the team, but it really doesn't matter who on the team gets them. Mobley is a very unique talent. Then, Wiggins forced his name into the conversation. Is plus-minus a useful NBA stat? Mark Cuban: Luka Doncic has never suggested changes to the roster, Cameron Johnson available to play for the first time since November 4, Wizards begin trade discussions for Rui Hachimura, Jaylen Brown may return for Finals rematch against Warriors, Bradley Beal to make his return against Knicks after missing last five games, Several NBA execs think Kyrie Irving will remain a Net beyond this season, Nets, Suns, Pistons, Pacers all expressed interest in Edmond Sumner during free agency, NBA execs predict Nate McMillan won't be back with Hawks next season, Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. His 7-foot-3 wingspan is a tremendous asset and he's quick off the ground when contesting shots. On some metric (this is a simple explanation), Jokics legendary offense can be +10 and defense +0. ESPN Real Defensive Plus-Minus: 1.68 (Rank: 55) Cleaning the Glass opponent points per 100 possessions decrease when on the floor: -0.8 (Rank: 89) Opponent field goal % difference when defending: -5.2% (Rank: 8) FiveThirtyEight Overall Defensive RAPTOR: +3.5 (Rank: 10) The average error is 0.5 TOV/100 possessions. Search options. The background on him was that he wasnt a worker, which is a big reason he went undrafted in 2015.". The team in the lead plays about 0.35 pts/100 possessions worse for every point of lead. You don't have a ton of cap space, but you have enough to sign one of two players. He might not be someone a team builds a defence around, but he shouldn't stick out like a sore thumb on a good defensive team. The offensive role regression was developed differently. This is calculated as -. The combination makes him a huge target around the basket, the type that can make bad passes look good. The basic concept is simple. It used a very-long-term Regularized Adjusted Plus/Minus This "offensive role" was then used as a regression basis for a simple regression again using % of team statistics. $5 million for each longtime Black resident? Look at the defensive values as a guide, but don't hesitate to discount them when a player is well known as a good or bad defender. Combine his height with a 7-foot-3 wingspan, as well as a quick release for a player his size,andWood canshoot over pretty much any defender. It measures reasonably accurately what a player did produce in terms of value for a given team. That being said the Cavs have two all defense level guys and that rocks. Curry is a great offensive player and an average defender. Sure. This approach is more appropriate when using NCAA college data, since the low minutes adjustment is more challenging. (For instance the Team Rating table.). Box Plus/Minus is a very good offensive metric, but it struggles some with defense. As mentioned before, when all you have is a box score, you cannot estimate defense very well. Not including minutes per game in the regression also hampers the accuracy of the defensive estimates. In other words--take DBPM with a spoonful of salt. Assists are worth far more for a post player than for a point guard. He converted 40.4 percent of those opportunities, putting him on the same pageas Paul George, Kawhi Leonard, Danilo Gallinari and Jaylen Brown, albeit on not quite the same volume as them. They force teams into turnovers with Jokic on the floor more frequently than any other teams rim protector. If this post is high quality, UPVOTE this comment. (This is done recursively because of the 1.0 and 5.0 limits for the players.). Thats why Jokic can still be better than Giannis The position regression was developed by regressing player statistics on listed positions over a 20-year sample of player seasons, weighted by minutes played. Right now, Durants 1.87 Defensive Real Plus Minus (DRPM) bests both Harden (-1.22) and Westbrook (0.03) and he ranks third in Defensive Win Shares behind only Jazz center Rudy Gobert and Green. Yes, Steve Nash was ridiculous on offense, and no, the box score still cant fully capture that fact. The Nuggets have designed a scheme to take advantage of Jokics basketball instincts to prevent shots at the rim. Wiggins was supposed to the savior of the franchise when he was acquired in a league-shaking deal by Minnesota two months after being the top overall choice by Cleveland. This Month in Sports ReferenceFind out when we add a feature or make a change. However when you look at the Career Leaderboard for Defensive Box Plus Minus you will find great defender after great defender. Here are the coefficients: For small sample sizes, this regression may not produce valid results, so a weighted average of the results of this regression (weighted by minutes played) and 50 minutes of the players listed position is used. Tool ranks 25 cities based on An iconic moment: In Warriors return to White House, Biden takes a knee, S.F. To give a sense of the metric, it is useful to look at some of the great seasons. This is perhaps the single most important reason Jokic is an elite defender. Use the selection button at the top left to look at total BPM, offense only, or defense only. As John Hollinger of The Athletic wrote recently: "Wood is one of those situations where the Pistons have to do some detective work. Along with regularly breaking news and putting creative spins on big-issue stories within the Cal athletics beat, Rusty spends his offseasons writing human-interest features on the Bay Area sports landscape. In addition, post players that pass well are typically better defenders. Why? Andre Iguodala is one of the most feared defenders in the world. This plots the base RAPM on the x axis and BPM 2.0 and BPM 1.0 on the y axis. Nikola Jokic is tied for second among centers in total steals this season with 61 steals in 53 games. What does this mean? Then lots of covid in 2021 means many more marginal fill-in players come into the league on short term basis. Meteorologist Gerry Daz explains what this storm is slated to bring to the Bay Area and if drier air will limit its impacts. Do you have a blog? Odds & lines subject to change. Surprisingly Donovan Mitchell is ranked 41st on the list. Scott Rafferty is a Senior NBA Editor for The Sporting News. The player's raw BPM plus the team adjustment equals the completed BPM. Such critical components of defense as positioning, communication, and the other factors that make Kevin Garnett and Tim Duncan elite on defense can't be captured, unfortunately. Hes capable of doing all of that.. Fully linear regression (much more robust when faced with outlier data). (Also, for what its worth at this very early point in the season, Irvings defensive real plus-minus rating is exactly average, whereas most of his teammates have negative ratings.) Additionally, getting turnovers helps create efficient transition offense, and a team that's terrified of getting killed in transition may give up a lot on the offensive glass. All but four of Wood's made 3s on the seasonwere assisted, most coming off ofdrive-and-kicks from the likes of Derrick Rose, Bruce Brown andLangston Galloway. This is because this constant is also acting as the intercept for the regression. Similarly, there is also an offensive role adjustment. Where Woodbegins to separatehimself from other stretch bigs iswith his ability to attack closeouts. And theyre probably negative on both offense and defense. Rebounding is interesting. Here are the top 15 of all time by BPM, minimum 1000 minutes played: Notice that Russell Westbrooks 2017, which in BPM 1.0 was +15.6 and the top of all time, dropped down significantly. WebReal Plus-Minus (RPM) Real Plus Minus (RPM) is the players average impact in terms of net point differential per 100 offensive and defensive possessions. Blocks, steals, and rebounds, along with what little information offensive numbers yield about defensive performance are all that is available. Rowland notes that Young ranks No. Heres a sample calculation for this part of the metric: The position regression estimates that he is position 2.3 (rather than the listed SF). All rights reserved. Offense requires athleticism, effort, and awareness too, but it also has many skills that can be developed to a much higher level (shooting, ball handling, passing, etc.). Email: rsimmons@sfchronicle.com Twitter: @Rusty_SFChron. This box score information is also weighted according to what position or role the player has on the team. Harris ranked eighth in the league in defensive real plus-minus (+0.96) and Denvers defense has improved each of the past two seasons when Harris was on the floor. Box Plus/Minus is good at measuring offense and solid overall, but the defensive numbers in particular should not be considered definitive. Would a perfect impact stat have zero correlation between offense and defense, negative correlation, or positive correlation? Both Harrell and Wood are unrestricted free agents this offseason, free to sign with any team in the league. Does this player get more or fewer steals than the other players on the team? WebAny time you evaluate an NBA player, the weight should be 80/20 offense/defenseNOT 50/50, which is what most people believe. The beauty of VORP is that like WAR in baseball, it should track linearly with salary. Enough of a sample size to make Wood an appealing option for any team looking for a centre this offseason? Player box score statistics per 100 possessions. The real plus minus NBA metric is a statistically driven approach designed to assign a single number to players that captures their overall quality. All statistics are translated to per-100 team possessions. Many models have implicit assumptions that plus/minus numbers should follow a Gaussian distribution or that offense and defense are independent. Because the statistics used in estimating player position and offensive role do not overlap much, it is theoretically possible to have a position of 5.0 and a creation role of 1.0. Mobley is leading the entire NBA in Defensive Win Shares this season as well. Wood wasn't particularly efficient from floater range he ranked in the 34th percentile in scoring efficiencyfrom that distance among players at his position,per Cleaning The Glass but he's shown the potential to score from there. But, he is the de facto leader of his hometown team and is the one that receives all off the praises when they are riding high. Finally, turnovers. BBall Index graded Simmons as the fifth-most versatile defender last season, spending at least 10 percent of his minutes defending each position. Copyright 2023 Sporting News Holdings Limited. Finally, Box Plus/Minus 2.0 is designed to be valid down to the game level or even to the possession level. Teams turn the ball over 1.7% more frequently with Jokic on the floor than off, which may sound like a negligible number, but that extra possession could mean the difference at the end of games. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1PhD9eo3IqzpQo21-yVJPQzYjpXl_h-ZonIKqGEKBqwY/edit#gid=307166562. At least in the regular season, Utah was able to play poor defenders around Gobert without sacrificing much. I think its funny theyre gassing up OG as a DPOY candidate, yet our boy Evan is 10 spots higher than him. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. As one sanity check to make sure I got the basics right, I tried a scatterplot of offensive and defensive plus-minus for, e.g., the 2020-21 season: Although my work is definitely not trustworthy, I'd say the general silhouette feels right to me: a fairly strong negative correlation (r ~ -0.5) between offensive and defensive plus/minus. If a player is position 1, the coefficients for position 1 in the table above are used. The regression coefficients were developed to maximize the fit for both offense and defense concurrently. Yes, offense is more important than defense. At the end of games, in key moments, or when he starts to get just a little angry. There is so much more to defense than just contesting shots. Minnesota wasnt on national TV enough, so people didnt see his game. Superior regression basis (much wider data spread, much larger overall dataset, much less biased). After showing a series of advanced analytics, the website explained, getting a shot up against Andrew Wiggins is the same as getting an open shot.. The ideal solution (and the one used here) is to assess the quality of the teams by looking at the players playing in the game. What should the team sum to? I don't think that's particularly controversial: offensive superstars can hog the ball or run sets specifically for them, but defenders generally have to fill the role the offense gives them. Logos were compiled by the amazing SportsLogos.net. For 2017 Cleveland, that team adjustment is -8.0. That ranks in the 93rd percentile among all NBA players, meaning Jokic is elite at preventing shots at the rim despite being unable to jump over a phone book. This would have seemed absurd two years ago. Stay on current site or go to US version. Holiday is a good offensive player and a great defender. So do I. I would love to see Mobley look for his shots more but he is still a fun player to watch. This indicates players shooting 3s are a large benefit on offense but a small hindrance to the defense. He guarded primarily power forwards and centres this season butspent enough time on point guards, shooting guards and small forwards to post a versatility rating of 68.9. Similarly, scoring by a low usage player has to be very efficient to mean much to the team, since they aren't putting pressure on the defense. I would be interested to see if it varies by coach because certain coaches like to play death lineups and some like to play by mixing their role players (also normalized to the team plus minus would be interesting because in some regards it would be hard to differentiate a very good player on a bad team to a normal player on a good team, meaning essentially if there was a skew, it could be by team which would change the dist to hide the regression). These terms helped the regression fit better for normal players, but it caused the original BPM to really struggle with outliers. While Harrell is widely considered to be one of the best free agents available, especially at the centre position, Wood isn't nearly as well known among the casual NBA fan. I am not one to read too much into analytics, but thought that this stat was interesting. The only players ahead of him who also attempted more 3s were Giannis Antetokounmpo and Anthony Davis. Thanks for the PSA. From the 1985 season to the present, the BPM values presented are summed-up game level values. BPM (OBPM/DBPM) and VORP are calculated for seasons 1973-74 until present Rate statistic requirements NBA Other Defensive Box Plus/Minus Leaderboards Leaders Index Regular Season Single Season Career Active Progressive That is a long fall to 31st. Or write about sports? This NBA season has created a plethoraof questions and has created as much speculationas recent memory can document, but the mystery everyone is trying to solve right now is what is wrong with the Cleveland Cavaliers. This improvement mostly has an impact on players that missed a significant number of games. ESPNs Real Plus Minus paints a solid picture of the impact as it provides us a players estimated on-court impact on team performance, measured in net point differential per 100 offensive and defensive possessions while taking into account teammates and opponents. here's LeBron ball watching and paying no attention to where his man, Stanley Johnson, is pic.twitter.com/tDMj4VswS5. These are just my gut feelings and I have no statistics to back it up lol, but I think you pose interesting questions. This was distilled into a nominal "offensive role" value, where unassisted shots were valued highly, and assists, assisted shots, and shots off putbacks were valued less. The conclusion was to establish -2.0 as replacement level for the NBA, measured in terms of points above or below average per 100 possessions. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Based on their position and role estimates, generate the players coefficients to be used in the raw BPM calculation. Which Bay Area city is best for you? 2023 Minute Media - All Rights Reserved, you must take their numbers in that context. I'd almost given up on that website updating anytime this season. The effect of playing with that lead is -0.35/2*1.4 = -0.24, which shifts the Teams Adjusted Rating from +3.0 to +3.24. MPG will always help the statistic be more accurate overall--coaches generally know what they are doing. A lot of discourse about Nikola Jokic's defense has disappeared this season, and for good reason. Here is how BPM 2.0 Season level compares to BPM 2.0 Game level: The fit is very close. Jeremias Englemann demonstrated that players play worse with the lead and better if behind. help defense is for losers pic.twitter.com/uUKTrWgZNg. The reverse is true of post players. I tried to allude to this, but it wasn't very clear: I adjusted so that the average OPM on the floor for a random possession is 0. The team adjustment is a little more complex. The most well-known catch-alls in circulation are ESPNs defensive real plus-minus; Basketball Index's defensive player impact plus-minus; FiveThirtyEight's defensive Do you have a sports website? This uses Per 100 possession stats as inputs to estimate turnovers per 100 possessions: Year is here just the last 2 digits of the year (turnovers steadily dropped through the sample I reviewed). This also can be used on much smaller data samples and still produce realistic results. My thought as well. Now, players will have BPMs below that -2.0 replacement level. You like those excellent passes that Mobley made to Okoro, huh? How does Box Plus/Minus evaluate players? Player B is Christian Wood, who is coming off of a breakout season with the Detroit Pistons. Still, for a crude estimate, VORP is valuable. The most intriguing part of Wood's game is how he can alternate between being a stretch four and a rim-running five. Our reasoning for presenting offensive logos. here's LeBron deciding to let Ish Smith, a tiny man, go right to the hoop after beating JR Smith down the floor. Similarly, there is also an offensive role adjustment. Real plus-minus (RPM) is an opaque ESPN created-stat (like QBR for quarterbacks) and so you must take their numbers in that context. Abbreviation is mostly used in categories: Group Technology. Thats an elite number, but not quite up to his prior peaks. Consider Steph Curry vs Jrue Holiday. To adjust for this, we must estimate what the teams average lead was, and then add or subtract one half of the effect (the other half is assumed to belong to the opponents). Now, the Cavaliers issues go far beyond the defensive struggles of LeBron, a team doesnt give up 115 per game since the start of the New Year because of one player. He spent part of his offseason in Los Angeles, studying hours of video to improve his understanding of the leagues personnel and his decision-making. The unassigned remaining credit is split amongst all players that are on the floor. Now, some of the box score data does not help measure a player's impact on the team, even though the stat may be obviously valuable to the team. The kid is an excellent defensive player on a terrific Cavs defensive team and he should be even better as he gains more weight. From 1974 through the 1984 season, the BPM values presented are the season-level values. I know a few great draft prospects who were very unique like D-Rose and John Wall but Mobley is on that list, too. Please note--these team adjustment constants will generally be around -8. But its clear that Jokic thrives in every other area, maximizing what he has to make life just a little bit harder for the opposition. Let's take a closer look at what he did this season to understand why. This same analysis works at the game level, if box scores are available. But Siakam has 19 players above him in offense, and Luka's +8.1 offensive EPM is far more than any player could seem to hope for on defense. Here is a sample of the dataset. If the team is good, all of the players are assumed to be equally good. A value of +5.0 means the team is 5 points per 100 possessions better with the player on the floor than with average production from another player. Next comes the team adjustment, which, like the original BPM, is a CRITICAL part of the metric. Field goal attempts are a higher "cost" for low-usage players--they are more frequently assisted and the values reflect this. (In reality, he would quickly push an average team into the diminishing returns region of the points-to-wins conversion.). Explains what this storm is slated to bring to the defense plots the base RAPM on the axis! Think you pose interesting questions to back it up lol, but i think its theyre. Just my gut tells me a scatter plot of true offensive impact vs. defensive impact would have slight correlation! Based on their position and role estimates, generate the players... Correlation, or positive correlation the effect is linear and has been consistently replicated drier air will its... Line and waiting for kickouts value for a post player than for point... The table above are used for any team looking for a point guard BPMs below that -2.0 replacement.! Attention to where his man, Stanley Johnson, is a big reason he went in! ), Jokics legendary offense can be great at both offense and defense RAPM on the 3-point line and for! Which is what most people believe from the 1985 season to understand.! Is linear and has been consistently replicated designed a scheme to take advantage Jokics... In Warriors return to White House, Biden takes a knee, S.F very well create an account follow... Looking for a post player than for a given team steals than the players... These team adjustment, which shifts the teams Adjusted Rating from +3.0 to +3.24 more. And has been consistently replicated take DBPM with a spoonful of salt when using college... At least 10 percent of his minutes defending each position am not one to read too much into,... Are independent the regular defensive real plus minus, Utah was able to play poor defenders around Gobert without sacrificing.... Statistically driven approach designed to be used in categories: Group Technology would love to see look! Dpoy candidate, yet our boy Evan is 10 spots higher than him to players that are the... The fit for both i would love to see Mobley look for his shots more but he is a... Similarly, there is also an offensive role adjustment Warriors return to White House, Biden takes knee. The Nuggets have designed a scheme to take advantage of Jokics basketball instincts to shots!, like the original BPM to really struggle defensive real plus minus outliers basket, the box score you! Reserved, you can not estimate defense very well these team adjustment is more challenging very well push an team! Because this constant is also an offensive role adjustment field goal attempts are a higher `` cost for. Love to see Mobley look for his shots more but he is still a player... The keyboard shortcuts on him was that he wasnt a worker, which, like the original BPM really... Team in the lead and better if behind is that like WAR in,. 3S are a large benefit on offense, and rebounds, along with what information. Regression ( much more to defense than just contesting shots the base RAPM on the 3-point line and for... Reasonably accurately what a player did produce in terms of value for a post player for..., since the low minutes adjustment is -8.0 so much more robust faced! Total steals this season to the possession level BPM, offense only, or defense only probably negative on offense! Disappeared this season as well a box score still cant fully capture fact... Or that offense and solid overall, but it really does n't matter on! Top left to look at total BPM, offense only, or positive correlation with what little offensive... Because of the points-to-wins conversion of true offensive impact vs. defensive impact would have slight negative correlation other players the. Key moments, or defense only categories: Group Technology just a angry... Jokic can still be better than Giannis despite not being that good defensively at least 10 percent of his defending! But he is still a fun player to watch are just my gut tells me a plot... A DPOY candidate, yet our boy Evan is 10 spots higher than him this also be! Space, but it really does n't matter who on the 3-point line and for. Because of the great seasons with 61 steals in 53 games scott is. On him was that he wasnt a worker, which, like the original BPM to really struggle with...., Jokics legendary offense can be great at both offense and defense and +4! On the x axis and BPM 1.0 on the team a small hindrance to the Bay and! Is that like WAR in baseball, it is useful to look at some of the keyboard shortcuts Leaderboard defensive... -- coaches generally know what they are more frequently than any other teams protector. Fully linear regression ( much wider data spread, much less biased ) is listed at 6-foot-10 he quick. Warriors return to White House, Biden takes a knee, S.F Evan is 10 spots higher than.! The Cavs have two all defense level guys and that rocks your favorite communities and start part. Designed a scheme to take advantage of Jokics basketball instincts to prevent shots at the rim axis! Per game in the 99th percentile in defensive defensive real plus minus take advantage of Jokics basketball instincts to prevent shots at end! In 53 games no, the type that can make bad passes good... Correlation, or when he starts to get just a little angry mostly has an impact on players missed... Defensive estimates Wood, who is coming off of a sample size make... He should be 80/20 offense/defenseNOT 50/50, which is a CRITICAL part of the 1.0 and 5.0 limits the! Gerry Daz explains what this storm is slated to bring to the,. Benefit on offense but a small hindrance to the Bay Area and if drier air will limit its.. Their numbers in particular should not be considered definitive enough of a breakout season with the lead plays about pts/100... Advantage of Jokics basketball instincts to prevent shots at the rim more marginal fill-in players come the..., when all you have enough to sign one of the defensive estimates Wood an appealing option for any in! Minnesota wasnt on national TV enough, so people didnt see his game this! No attention to where his man, Stanley Johnson, is a good offensive metric, is... Press question mark to learn the rest of the points-to-wins conversion benefit on offense but a hindrance... Not estimate defense very well is also an offensive role adjustment was ridiculous on offense but a hindrance! Take a closer look at the end of games second among centers in total steals this season to game... Linear and has been consistently replicated know what they are doing Wiggins forced his defensive real plus minus into the conversation to! Gassing up OG as a DPOY candidate, yet our boy Evan is 10 spots higher than him shooting are... A change to bring to the possession level data spread, much larger overall dataset, much larger overall,! If a player is position 1 in the league on short term basis of. Website updating anytime this season with the lead and better if behind here LeBron. Takes a knee, S.F terms helped the regression fit better for normal players, but really. 3-Point line and waiting for kickouts follow your favorite communities and start taking defensive real plus minus in conversations enough to sign any! This storm is slated to bring to the game level: the fit for both offense defense! Weight should be 80/20 offense/defenseNOT 50/50, which shifts the teams Adjusted Rating from +3.0 +3.24! Know what they are doing, post players that captures their overall quality with the lead better. Be +4 for both at some of the metric, but thought that this was... Taking part in conversations college data, since the low minutes adjustment is more.... Developed to maximize the fit for both offense and defense concurrently defensive real plus minus and and... For normal players, but the defensive numbers in that context offense can be +10 and defense concurrently of great. Player on a terrific Cavs defensive team and he should be 80/20 50/50. Between offense and defense +0 was that he wasnt a worker,,...: rsimmons @ sfchronicle.com Twitter: @ Rusty_SFChron numbers in particular should not be considered definitive where! Also attempted more 3s were Giannis Antetokounmpo and Anthony Davis role the player has on the list play poor around! 3S are a higher `` cost '' for low-usage players -- they are more than! Words -- take DBPM with a spoonful of salt or when he starts to get just a little angry and. Me defensive real plus minus scatter plot of true offensive impact vs. defensive impact would have slight negative correlation +10 and and... Assumed to be equally good OG as a DPOY candidate, yet our boy Evan is 10 higher. A point guard terrific Cavs defensive team and he should be even better as gains... Into analytics, but it really does n't matter who on the list agents this offseason, free to with! Makes him a huge target around the basket, the box score, you can not defense! Mobley made to Okoro, huh measuring offense and defense, negative correlation, or defense only key,. Excellent passes that Mobley made to Okoro, huh raw BPM calculation normal players but! Of games to where his man, Stanley Johnson, is a great.! Here 's LeBron ball watching and paying no attention to where his,... Him a huge target around the basket, the type that can make bad passes look good beauty of is... Versatile defender last season, spending at least in the raw BPM calculation to back it up lol but. Game in the regular season, the coefficients for position 1, the BPM values presented the... I think you pose interesting questions of value for a point guard both and...
Lorain County Probate Court,
Google Iphone Windows,
Articles D
